Zrooth
Menu

Blog · Hiring

What Employers Should Ask For Instead of Degrees

4 November 2026 · 9 min read

Instead of a degree, ask candidates for four things: a short work sample from the real job, an account of how they use AI and where it fails them, a piece of their own thinking, and a view on what they would change in your business. That is skills-based hiring in practice, and it tells you far more about day one than a transcript does.

This article is for employers and hiring managers in India, the UAE, Kenya and elsewhere who suspect the degree filter is costing them good people but are not sure what to put in its place. It covers why the degree is a weak signal, the four requests in detail, how to score them, and the mistakes that make "we dropped the degree" a change in name only.

Why Is a Degree a Weak Signal for Most Roles?

A degree tells you a person committed to a course of study and finished it. That is a real signal of persistence. What it does not tell you is how the person will handle the specific work in front of them: how they break down a messy problem, how they write to a customer, how they check their own numbers.

Many employers keep asking for a degree because they have nothing better to ask for. It is easy to screen on, easy to defend, and it shrinks a large applicant pool quickly. The cost is invisible: capable people without the credential never reach the shortlist, and people with the credential but without the skills reach it easily.

Dropping the Requirement Is Not Enough

Plenty of firms have announced that they no longer require degrees. The evidence suggests announcements are the easy part. Research published in February 2024 by the Burning Glass Institute and the Harvard Business School Project on Managing the Future of Work concluded that many companies have announced dropping degree requirements, but sustained hiring changes remain elusive for most. If the screening, the interviews and the hiring managers' habits stay the same, the old filter simply comes back informally. Skills-based hiring needs something to ask for instead.

The Four Requests That Tell You More

Each request below is cheap to set up, works for most professional roles, and produces evidence you can compare across candidates.

1. A Short Work Sample From the Real Job

Take a small, real task from the role and ask candidates to do it. For a finance role: reconcile a short list of transactions and flag what looks wrong. For customer support: reply to three real (anonymised) customer messages. For marketing: rewrite one landing-page section for a named audience.

The US Office of Personnel Management's guidance on work samples and simulations notes that tasks which mirror the job tend to relate closely to job performance and that applicants often see them as very fair. It also flags the trade-off: good tasks take effort to design and score. Keep the early task to an hour or less, and pay for anything longer.

2. How They Use AI, and Where It Fails Them

Ask: "Walk me through a recent piece of work where you used an AI tool. What did it do well, what did it get wrong, and how did you check?" The answer shows two things a degree cannot: whether the person gets real leverage from tools everyone now has, and whether they know where those tools break.

This matters because most roles are being reshaped rather than replaced. The International Labour Organization's 2023 study on generative AI and jobs found that the main effect of the technology is likely to augment rather than automate jobs. People who can work alongside it, and catch its mistakes, are worth finding. Our article on which skills AI makes obsolete and which it rewards goes deeper.

3. A Piece of Their Own Thinking

Ask for something the candidate has already made: a short analysis, a process they mapped, a problem they solved and wrote up. Original work shows how a person chooses a question, handles evidence and reaches a conclusion. It also shows initiative, because nobody asked them to produce it.

If candidates have nothing to show, that is not automatically a mark against them, especially early in a career. You can offer the work sample instead. But a growing number of people are building public bodies of research for exactly this reason, as we explain in why original research is the new résumé.

4. What They Would Change About Your Business

For senior or commercial roles, share a short brief about one part of your business and ask: "After a week here, what would you look at first, and why?" You are not looking for the right answer. You are looking for the quality of the questions, whether they ask about customers and numbers before proposing fixes, and whether they can say what they would need to know before acting.

How to Score Skills-Based Hiring Evidence Fairly

Asking for better evidence only helps if you judge it consistently. Without a rubric, a work sample becomes another place for gut feel to hide.

  1. Write the criteria before you post. List three to five things the person must be able to do in the first three months. Map each one to a request above.
  2. Build a simple scale. For each criterion, describe what weak, adequate and strong look like in one sentence each.
  3. Score blind where you can. Remove names, institutions and photos from work samples before reviewers see them.
  4. Use two reviewers. Each scores separately, then they compare. Large gaps usually mean a criterion was unclear.
  5. Structure the interview too. The OPM's guidance on structured interviews describes how asking every candidate the same job-related questions and scoring against benchmarks increases agreement between interviewers.
  6. Review after each hiring round. Check whether the people who scored well are doing well. Adjust the tasks that did not predict anything useful.

An Illustrative Example: Hiring an Operations Coordinator

The following is illustrative, not a real case. Imagine a small logistics firm in Nairobi hiring an operations coordinator. The old advert asked for a business degree and three years' experience, and attracted a large pile of similar CVs.

The new advert lists three outcomes for the first quarter: keep the daily dispatch schedule accurate, cut the number of customer status calls, and document two core processes. Applicants are asked to look at a one-page description of a delayed delivery and say, in under 300 words, where the process broke and what they would change. Shortlisted candidates explain how they would use an AI tool to draft the process documents and how they would check them.

The firm reviews a shorter list, scored against the same criteria, and interviews for depth. Some of the strongest submissions may come from people without the old degree. Some will come from people with it. The point is that the decision now rests on evidence about the work.

Common Mistakes With Skills-Based Hiring

  • Removing the degree from the advert but not from the screen. If recruiters still filter on it, nothing has changed.
  • Long unpaid tasks. They put off strong candidates and favour those with free time. Keep early tasks short.
  • Tasks that test the wrong thing. A brain-teaser for a role that is mostly writing customer emails measures nothing useful.
  • Ignoring legal and regulatory requirements. Some roles genuinely require a specific qualification or licence by law, for example in regulated professions. Check the rules in your market and take professional advice where needed.
  • Treating evidence as the decision. Evidence informs judgement. Someone still has to decide, and that should be the employer.

How Zrooth Supports Skills-Based Hiring

Zrooth Jobs is a verified recruitment gateway: companies are verified before they post, and applications carry structured assessments and video introductions so evaluation starts from evidence. Our companion article on why verified hiring beats the CV explains the sequence. For deeper evidence of how someone thinks, Zrooth Platforms lets people publish scored research on real business problems, and employers can see it on their profiles.

If you are building an organisation that wants its whole team working this way, the AI Entrepreneurship Programme offers business consulting and training in applied AI. You will find more on hiring and talent on our Insights page. Throughout, the principle holds: we verify; employers decide. No platform or method can promise a good hire; better evidence just makes the decision easier to get right.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What is skills-based hiring?

It is hiring that judges candidates on evidence of the skills a role needs, such as work samples and structured interviews, rather than on proxies like a degree, a previous title or the name of a past employer.

Should employers remove degree requirements entirely?

For most roles, a degree is not the best filter, but some regulated professions legally require a specific qualification. Remove it where it is only a proxy, keep it where the law or the work genuinely needs it.

Is it fair to ask candidates for unpaid work?

A short task of an hour or less is widely accepted as part of an application. Anything longer, or anything you could use commercially, should be paid. Never use candidate work in your business without agreement.

What if a candidate has no portfolio of their own thinking?

Offer the work sample instead. Many capable people, especially early in their careers, have never been asked to publish their work. Missing a portfolio should not count against them on its own.

How do I stop interviewers from bringing the degree filter back informally?

Remove names and institutions from work samples before review, give interviewers a scoring guide tied to the role's criteria, and check which factors actually drove each shortlisting decision after the round.

What should I listen for when candidates describe how they use AI?

Listen for specifics: the task, the tool, what it got wrong and how they checked it. Vague enthusiasm or blanket rejection both tell you less than a clear account of one real piece of work.

Does skills-based hiring work for small businesses?

Yes, and it can be easier there, because the hiring manager often knows the real work closely. A one-page task and a short structured interview are enough to start, with no special software.

Does Zrooth Jobs make hiring decisions for employers?

No. Zrooth Jobs verifies employers and candidates and attaches structured assessments to applications. The employer reviews the evidence and makes every hiring decision.

Pathfinder · Free

Where Do You Fit in the AI Economy?

Type your industry and the work you do. See the live businesses you would learn inside, your twelve weeks, and three venture ideas made for you.

Find My Path

Join the Discussion

Agree, disagree or add your own experience. Every comment is reviewed before it appears; spam and abuse are removed, and disagreement is welcome.

    Add Your View

    0 / 2,000
    Links send a comment to manual review. Please do not share personal details about other people.